PB+J Thumbprint Cookies
These easy 5-ingredient cookies are the perfect sweet bite. These easy 5-ingredient cookies are the perfect sweet bite.
TRY MORE RECIPES for healthier cookies
NUTRITION PER SERVING (Read more)
Notes
If milling your own flax seeds 1 ¼ tablespoons whole seeds will yield 2tbsp milled.
Ingredients
Method
Gather and prepare your ingredients. Line a baking tray with parchment paper. Preheat the oven to 180°C/160°C fan.
Place the flax seeds and water into a bowl and whisk to combine. Set aside to soak for 15 minutes until it has formed a gel.
Place the peanut butter, brown sugar, oats and soaked flax into a bowl and stir to combine.
Use a tablespoon measure to scoop them onto your baking tray. If desired, lightly dampen your hands and shape the cookies into more perfect circles.
Poke your finger into the middle of each cookie to create a small crater. It helps to dip your finger in water before doing this.
Fill each indentation with a small amount of jam.
Bake for 10-12 minutes, until darkened and flattened. Allow to cool completely on the baking tray.
Notes
If milling your own flax seeds 1 ¼ tablespoons whole seeds will yield 2tbsp milled.
Available to new users joining a yearly plan only. Ends 30/11/2026.
User comments (14)
Very nice. Really easy to make, slightly crumbly , I doubled the mixture and used coconut sugar not brown sugar. It was slightly savory but very nice
double the amounts - for your overall effort, making 10 feels a bit funny even for 2 skinny ppl :)
Batter was too wet to make cookies with (used natural peanut butter), had to add 2 tbsp of oats & 3/4 tsp of psyllium husks, was still too sticky.. turned out very chewy and soft. maybe add more time in the oven :)
These cookies are so quick and easy to make. Really tasty too.
My son loved these!
Love these. Nicest cookies ever. In less than 30 minutes you’ve got healthy fresh cookies
I let my toddler make the thumbprints in these cookies. They were a daily snack this week and a great success. I used a teaspoon to measure out each cookie - this was the right size for us and made approx. 15, I think. I'll make them again and will experiment with different fruit flavours- maybe mango next. These are definitely going into my toddler-friendly snack rotation!
I wasn’t able to increase the number of servings high enough to make a big batch of cookies. I had to double the max, but it still worked great.
A bit too much peanut taste for me. Shall try with almond butter.
Easy peasy and delicious. Used homemade bramble jam. A definite thumbs up!
Delicious! So gooey and nutty with a hit of sweetness from jam. I think you could even add less sugar to the mix if glucose is an issue. I heartily recommend these!
I cooked these for longer as they were a bit soft for our taste. Drier was better for us. Definitely made 10 or 11 portions
Yummy, my son loves them!
Absolutely delicious but there’s no way that recipe makes 10, just about made 6
Delicious and so quick and easy.